First They Came for the 'Gypsies'...
By J. B. GeraldFirst they came for the Communists, but I wasn't a Communist so I didn't speak out. Then they came for the Socialists and the Trade Unionists, but I was neither, so I didn't speak out. Then they came for the Jews, but I wasn't a Jew so I didn't speak out. And when they came for me, there was no one left to speak out for me. - Martin Niemöller
In Paris October 7th, several hundred gathered in the place du Panthéon for a Roma Pride rally, an affirmation of Roma identity at a time when the Roma face ongoing and unacceptable persecution in France and throughout the European Union. Small gatherings for Roma Pride in fourteen EU countries were reported. While the European Union backs policies of integrating the Roma into society, in fact criminal acts and agendas of violence particularly in Hungary and the Czech Republic are mirrored by programs of "camp clearing" and expulsions in nations with more advanced bureaucracies.
Media coverage of the persecution in France is sporadic; cafebabel.com reports that 400 Roma were expelled in the last two months. In Marseilles on Sept. 27th, vigilantes burned a Roma camp of 35. With nowhere to go the homeless victims remained in the area and the Town Hall is currently (as of Oct. 11) demanding their departure. Press reports lack any assurance that the Roma adults and children have minimal recourse to food, shelter, and government protection. Near the border with Belgium a bulletin in La Voix du Nord, announces the Rom encampment at Faubourg-de-Béthun (Lille) will be closed toward the end of October, but with some thought for accommodation of the displaced.
Roms as a vulnerable group historically (ie. at least half a million died in Nazi concentration camps), appear frequently in notations of early genocide warnings for Europe since 2006 ("Genocide warnings," nightslantern.ca). Under President Sarkozy France's banning of the Islamic full face veil in July 2010, was followed by his campaign to clear France of Roma. (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15). So the small Roma Pride rallies of October 7, 2012, occur within a context of a rightist extremism threatening all vulnerable minorities. Parallels to early Nazi campaigns of the 1930's remain, gloved in policies that kill slowly. Forms of racism against Arabs, Jews, Roms and Black Africans knit a "white" majority's vote as far right French politicians protest "anti-white racism" and epithets like "chalk face" (rfi).
Benjamin Abtan of EGAM (Le Mouvement Antiraciste Européen), an organizer of the October 7th rally laid out its tenets in newspaper articles calling for the an end to the racist acts, an end to expulsions without alternative lodgings, an end to the law of January 3, 1969 which remains partially in effect requiring travel papers for Travelers, an end to the 3% only quota for a Roma community in towns, among other points all within a context of anti-racism. He describes "Roma Pride" as "a mobilization of and a support system for self-emancipation, carried out regardless of the origins of individuals and organizations involved, since Universalism is our inspiration, and the full integration our shared demand."
From outside of France, The New Statesman quotes Marian Mandache of Romani Crisis in Roumania: "We believe that the French government, be it right-wing or left-wing, UMP or PS, is mainly looking at ways to reduce numbers, following the idea that Roma people should leave France..." It remains difficult to find in European and U.S. media, evidence (names, dates, witnesses, exact location) of acts against Roms which may be crimes under international law though permitted or unprosecuted domestically. In this way the media colludes with the persecution.
Current Canadian immigration policy re. Roma immigration provides an insight into how vulnerable minorities are to be dealt with by the NATO alliance. From Hungary where reports suggest that violence against Roms is police protected, Roma rights activist Guyula Kanto and his family escaped to Canada. Rejection of their appeal for asylum was assured by decision of Federal Court, Sept. 5th. And on Sept. 5th in his show, "The Source" / "The Jew vs. the Gypsies", for Quebecor's Sun Media News, Ezra Levant, levelled an extremist and defamatory diatribe against "Gypsies" enforcing stereotypes to portray the entire people as criminals. If the words were applied to any other minority group, Levant, an attorney, would possibly be fired or charged with a hate crime. He was not. Previously, Levant introduced the right wing Dutch MP Geert Wilders speaking on the dangers of Islam, May 10th, 2011 at the National Arts Centre in Ottawa (Wilders publicly denigrated and insulted Mohammed from Toronto) as the Conservative government extended its Libya mission. In both cases a seriously offensive attack on a vulnerable minority serves the policies of the Conservative government.
France offers no broad political alliance of the victim groups, each challenged by the rise of European fascism and accommodation by the left. Organizations of Rom, Muslims, Jews, the elderly, student organizations, former colonial peoples, the LGT community, Unions, Communists, as well as Gaullist groups, Greens, military and veterans organizations, might differ strongly but unite in their refusal to persecute.
Partial sources online: "La 'Roma Pride': une marche pour dire non aux persécutions," Benjamin Abtan, Oct. 5, 2012, Le nouvel observateur; "Roma Pride : de la dignité et de l’égalité en Europe," Benjamin Abtan, Oct. 7, 2012, La Règle du Jeu; "March for the Dignity of Roma People in Europe," Benjamin Abtan, Oct. 6, 2012, Hurriyet Daily News; "The Roma in France Is Hollande going to expel us all," Valeria Costa-Kostritsky, Oct. 1, 2012, NewStatesman; "Angry locals set fire to Rom camp in Marseille," Angela Diffley, Sept. 28, 2012, rfi; : "Residents of Creneaux insist Romani people must leave town," Romea.cz, Oct. 11, 2012, Roma Solidarity News; "Expulsions : la France reprend du Rom," Oct. 11, 2012, cafebabel.com; Les Roms de l'église des Victoires vont être (en partie) installés à Hellemmes," La Voix du Nord, Oct. 13, 2012, La Voix du Nord; "Roma in Hungary feel persecuted but they have nowhere to turn," Rick Westhead, Oct. 13, 2012, thestar.com; "Canada rejects Roma activist despite claims of neo-Nazi attacks in Hungary," Gary Dimmock, Oct. 9, 2012, The Ottawa Citizen; "Right-wing leader claims 'anti-white racism' growing in France," Tony Cross, Sept. 27, 2012, rfi; "Coordinated protests against racism held in 14 European countries," G. Dunkel, Oct. 12, 2012, Workers World; "Statement Concerning Hate Speech in Canadian Media," Roma Community Centre, Sept. 10, 2012, Roma Solidarity News.
By John Bart Gerald, Oct.14, 2012
Author posted Oct.14, 2012
gerald and maas